Peanut Butter Jelly Time

Published: Tue, 07/11/17

Good morning ,

Hope your week is off to great start! Let's talk Peanut Butter; it's so good right?!

I had some fascinating conversations this past weekend about fat loss, health, and diet (what folks eat), not as in a diet protocol! I'm always on duty, it appears -I love it though. My hopes is that I can change at least one women's mind to let go of the diet mentality and move to a sane approach to health and fitness.

Some ladies and I were discussing Peanut Butter and the importance of protein. Lol, peanut butter of all things, was one of the many conversations that went on. Peanut butter is soo yummy and tasty, right?!. Very hard to not eat the whole jar when you have a scarcity mindset around food. 

Psst... In my yo-yo dieting days, I could slam a whole jar in less than a week. More on that later....

Anywho, the interesting part is that most folks believe Peanut Butter is a viable protein source. We have been told that for many, many years through the food pyramid. In actuality it is not a protein, it's a fat source. It has protein in it, but it's a fat source first.

The look on the ladies faces was priceless, and their jaws were on the floor. Like really?! Yes, really!

I thought it was good for you, but it's healthy, they said! Why, yes it is. That doesn't mean that we can eat it to excess without any consequences, especially if you eat it multiple times a day with no idea as to how much you are actually eating. Even healthy foods have calories, and anything in excess will cause fat gain.

One of the ladies mentioned she goes in on the PB, meaning she can kill a jar in short amount of time. Then she goes on and says this is because I don't eat anything else that is sweet and it's a good source of protein, which I explained it is not.

A light bulb goes off in my head! Let me break down why you are eating a whole jar. You already know what I am about to say. You are restricting too much, which ultimately leads to binging.

It could be that you banned, or restricted carbs, or it could be that you gave up your favorite piece of chocolate now and then. Therefore, we substitute Peanut Butter because it can satisfy our sweet tooth. However, it takes so much to do so, sometimes a whole jar in days. Am I right or am I wrong?!

I know this, because I went through this in my dieting days. Anytime I was able to have it, I would eat it like it was going out of style. I mean, I would eat it till my stomach would hurt. That's what restriction-binge cycle does to you….then enters the guilt and shame.

I had to do the work to get Free off the diet mentality. Exposure to foods, trust, and cultivating an abundance mindset towards all foods. 

On another note, ever heard the song below?!

Peanut butter jelly time, I love me a good ole Peanut Butter Jelly sandwich with a Protein shake on the side, lol. In my Peanut Butter Jelly time voice.


Peanut butter is a healthy source of fat, no doubt about it. However, if you were to eat enough to serve as a viable protein source, you would be eating 748 calories, 64g of fat, 28g of carbs, and 30g of protein.

So, you see how much you have to eat for it to equal a good amount of protein per meal? In comparison to say, tuna fish, a chicken breast, or even a protein shake.

  • Tuna Fish- 4 oz, 132 calories, 0.9g of fat, 0 carbs, 29g of Protein
  • Chicken breast - 4.5 oz or 1 Chix breast, 139 calories, 1.5 g of fat, 0 carbs, 29g of protein
  • Protein Shake- 1 scoop, 145 calories, 2g of fat, 4g of carbs, 30 of protein

Now, as you know, I do not promote any foods to be off limits. This is not what I am saying - enjoy your PB, but know that it is not a protein source, it is a fat source.

Rule of thumb when telling if something is a good source of protein is that if the protein grams are higher than the fat per serving, it probably is. For example, with the topic at hand, per 2 tbsp, PB has 16 g of Fat and 8 grams of Protein. So, as you can see PB is very, very low on the protein scale.


My favorite brand of Peanut Butter! 
I generally recommend my clients aim for 25 - 30 grams of protein per meal, and for total daily intake,  .7g to 1g per pound of bodyweight. If you follow this protocol, you can watch your hunger, energy, and cravings get all the way in check!

The PB Sandwich or an apple or banana and PB are great snacks with filling power, but they are missing the protein component. Why do we need the Protein component? #BecauseMuscles, satiety, and fullness factor - protein takes alot energy to burn (digest), and not only that, it has many amino acids that our bodies need.

What are some other sources of Protein:
  • Eggs
  • Steak
  • Egg whites
  • Turkey
  • Fish

Lastly, enjoy your PB, but be mindful of the portions, unless that's the only fat you are eating for the day!

Hit reply, and let me know what your wins or struggles are these days in relation to fitness, nutrition, or mindset.

You can also book a Chemistry call and we can hop on a call troubleshoot your fitness and nutrition regimen so that you can stop spinning your wheels. Book the call below!